A price shown per month does not tell you how often you will be charged, how long you commit, or what happens if you stop. On Dropbox's public page, selecting yearly billing showed US$9.99 per month; selecting monthly billing showed US$11.99. Adobe's Japan page displayed a monthly payment under an annual contract with a cancellation condition alongside it.

We checked four providers' public pages on October 24, 2026, without buying, logging into customer accounts or reading personal bills. The observations below are dated evidence, not permanent prices, personal offers or a recommendation to switch. Unknown fields stay unknown instead of becoming zero.

Four public observations, with the billing context attached

Page and scopeDisplay observedBilling contextStill not verified
Apple US iCloud+, 50 GBUS$0.99/monthMonthly public pricePersonal tax and checkout total
Google One, Basic 100 GB, USD displayUS$1.99/moPublic monthly displayBilling country, annual invoice and tax
Dropbox, Plus 2 TB, USD browser viewUS$9.99/mo yearly selection; US$11.99/mo monthly selectionBoth radio states and prices observed in the public browserBilling country, final annual invoice and tax
Adobe Japan Acrobat, Pro individual¥2,530/month including taxAnnual plan paid monthlyAccount-specific cancellation quote and adjustments

The services and capacities differ. Do not rank these four rows as interchangeable products, add yen to dollars, or infer billing country from the language of the page. A localized address did not establish every pricing field in our checks. We recorded the displayed currency and the missing scope instead of forcing all rows into one country.

In a later public-page check on November 4, 2026, Google One Basic 100 GB appeared as €1.99 per month. On November 6 the public response showed $1.99 per month again. We did not establish the billing country or control the billing selector for those two responses. The different currencies are observations, not proof of a price change or an exchange rate; the October 24 row and downloadable calculations remain a historical snapshot. Check the provider's current terms for your own country and purchase channel.

What the Dropbox selector proves, and what it does not

The checked yearly radio beside a US$9.99 monthly display proves that the display belongs to the yearly selection. It does not prove a customer will receive a US$9.99 monthly charge. We then clicked the monthly radio and observed US$11.99. This was a public display change, not a subscription or account change.

If twelve monthly payments stay at 11.99, their base total is 143.88. Multiplying the yearly selection's displayed monthly equivalent by twelve gives 119.88, a difference of 24.00. That second number is a calculation from the display, not a final annual invoice we observed. It assumes the equivalent is exact and that tax, fees and eligibility are comparable; rounding or checkout adjustments can matter.

The distinction matters most for short use. A lower monthly equivalent does not make an annual commitment behave like three independent monthly payments. Dropbox's cancellation help says an individual paid plan changes to Basic at the end of the current billing cycle. Its refund page describes a generally non-refundable policy with regional and purchase-channel exceptions. We did not determine any customer's refund entitlement.

An annual contract paid monthly still has a remaining term

Adobe Japan's page identifies the ¥2,530 Pro price as an annual plan paid monthly, including tax. It also states a fee of half the remaining annual commitment when cancelling after 14 days. That is different from assuming payments stop with no further cost as soon as use stops.

To expose that difference, our model holds that published rate and rule fixed. Assume four full monthly payments have been made, eight remain and there are no other adjustments. Four payments are ¥10,120. Eight remaining payments total ¥20,240; half is ¥10,120. Paid amounts plus the modeled fee total ¥20,240, compared with ¥30,360 for twelve unchanged payments.

This is conditional arithmetic at a specified point, not a personal cancellation quote, a refund calculation or advice to terminate. We did not verify promotions, prorating, contract changes or an actual account balance. Confirm those before treating a model as the amount due.

Cancellation request, effective date and refund are separate facts

Apple's iCloud+ help says the downgrade or cancellation takes effect after the current subscription billing period. It also tells users to deal with content exceeding the reduced storage capacity. A lower future bill is not the whole decision if the remaining service cannot hold the stored content.

Google One's help says purchased storage remains for the subscription term and purchases are non-refundable in most countries or regions. It directs App Store purchasers through Apple for the relevant changes or refund request. “Can cancel” therefore does not by itself mean an immediate refund or an immediate loss of every paid benefit.

Record three separate dates: request, service change and next or final charge. Add the purchase channel and where the confirmation is kept. We did not check personal records, so none of those dates can be supplied for a particular reader. Before reducing storage, check the provider's actual quota consequences and preserve needed content.

Keep illustrative savings separate from observed offers

Our earlier five calculations remain useful as controlled examples. Their numbers are invented currency units, not any of the providers' offers above. Staying costs 40 per month in the first four rows; the alternative begins at 28 with a one-off cost of 60. Additional tax and fees are assumed equal unless shown.

Fictional comparisonStayingAlternativeDifference
12 months at constant 2848028 × 12 + 60 = 39684 less
6 months at 28, then 6 at 3848028 × 6 + 38 × 6 + 60 = 45624 less
Same promotion, 40 added overlap480456 + 40 = 49616 more
Only 3 months at constant 2812028 × 3 + 60 = 14424 more
12 months: 9.99 versus 9.49, fee 10119.889.49 × 12 + 10 = 123.884 more

The constant-rate case breaks even after five months: 60 ÷ (40 − 28) = 5. That shortcut fails if the discount expires, and it does not determine the terms of a real contract. Only add overlapping bills caused by the change; a payment owed under both choices belongs on both sides.

Use the worksheet only after classifying the inputs

The calculator below assumes constant monthly rates and entered one-off costs. For the first fictional row, 40, 28, 60 and 12 reproduce 480 versus 396. It cannot verify a price, infer a refund, expand a stepped promotion or supply an unknown exit fee.

Our new script multiplies Apple's observed 0.99 by twelve to give 11.88 and Google's 1.99 by twelve to give 23.88 only under an unchanged-rate assumption. Those are not verified annual offers. The observations deliberately leave actual annual invoices and individual refund entitlement blank. The tax gate returns an incomplete result if tax or fees are unknown, even when it can calculate a base subtotal.

Download the observations and reproduce the bounded calculations

The dated observation CSV, Python source and complete results contain public URLs, missing fields and assumptions. Run python3 subscription-check.py if Python 3 is already available. It uses embedded public facts, not a live scraper; it reads no personal files, accounts or network.

The code checks the displayed-price arithmetic, the four-payment model, unknown tax and unknown fee handling. It rejects five altered inputs: missing amount, negative amount, non-finite amount, fractional period and mixed-currency subtraction. These checks validate the calculation rules, not the continued accuracy of the provider's page.

The earlier five-case CSV, results and JavaScript source remain available. Keep current official terms alongside any comparison. A defensible result can be “the quote is incomplete” or “keep the current service”; a visible discount alone does not establish a saving.

Use the worksheet

Enter only what you need. Inputs stay on this page unless you choose browser saving or download a file. No account identifiers are needed. Local saving is off by default; do not use it on a shared device.

Use one currency and a consistent tax basis. Convert yearly charges to monthly amounts first. Enter current, alternative and combined one-off costs in every row; enter 0 only for a cost you know is zero. The comparison is unavailable while an amount is unknown. Check any other fees, taxes, price changes and contract conditions separately.

ServiceCurrent monthly costAlternative monthly costOne-off change costsConditions to checkActions

Calculation check: the fictional example compares 30/month with 25/month plus 20 over 12 months: 360 versus 320, a difference of 40. This simple calculator assumes constant monthly prices; use separate manual calculations for introductory rates or changing charges.