An item starts at 100 price units. A 20% reduction makes it 80. Increasing that new price by 20% adds 16, leaving 96. The two labels cancel on paper, but the amounts do not: the decrease used 100 as its base and the increase used 80.

This note uses constructed prices, not a sale we observed or a purchase we made. Shipping, taxes, membership conditions and rounding at checkout are excluded unless a row explicitly adds a condition. The purpose is to check a price calculation before comparing actual offers.

Write the base beside every percentage

A reduction of r percent multiplies the current price by (1 − r/100). An increase multiplies it by (1 + r/100). Applying both changes means multiplying the factors, not adding the percentages.

Starting priceFirst operationSecond operationFinal price
100Reduce by 20%: 80Increase by 20%: 9696
100Reduce by 10%: 90Reduce by 20%: 7272
100Reduce by 30%: 70No second change70
100Increase by 20%: 120Reduce by 20%: 9696
100Reduce by 20%: 80Increase by 25%: 100100

A 10% reduction followed by 20% is a combined 28% reduction in this uncapped model. A single 30% reduction leaves 70 rather than 72. The difference is two price units per item; it is not two additional percentage points taken from the already reduced price.

Recovering the original price needs a different rate

After a 20% reduction, the missing 20 must be measured against 80. Since 20 ÷ 80 = 0.25, a 25% increase restores 100. More generally, divide the original price by the current price, subtract one, and multiply by 100 to obtain the required percentage increase. This formula needs a positive current price; a zero price has no finite percentage increase that recovers a positive starting value.

For a larger reduction the distinction grows. Halving 100 leaves 50, and recovering the other 50 requires a 100% increase. This is arithmetic about changing denominators, not a forecast of future prices or returns.

Fixed coupons make the order matter

Pure percentage factors commute: 100 × 0.8 × 0.9 equals 100 × 0.9 × 0.8, both 72. That does not mean every promotion can be rearranged. A fixed coupon acts by subtraction.

With a 10-unit coupon and a 20% discount, applying the percentage first gives 100 × 0.8 − 10 = 70. Applying the coupon first gives (100 − 10) × 0.8 = 72. The difference is the discount on the coupon's ten units. A minimum purchase threshold, a maximum discount or excluded products can change eligibility as well as arithmetic. Read the actual checkout terms before choosing an order; these examples do not establish a retailer's policy.

Keep three lines from the checkout

Record the eligible starting amount, each operation in the applied order and the final payable amount. Compare that final amount with the other offer for the same quantity and delivery conditions. If the displayed discount uses a different reference price, keep that reference separate from what you would otherwise pay.

Download the calculation data and the Python source. The source uses decimal arithmetic and explicitly checks the zero-price exception. It reads no private account information and makes no network requests. These finite checks establish the stated examples, not the terms of a live promotion.